Adrian Goldberg

Adrian Goldberg is an award winning journalist and broadcaster, born in Birmingham. He has presented across BBC Radio 4, 5 Live and BBC WM, including 5 Live Investigates, and is now editor and presenter of the Byline Times podcast. He has written for the Birmingham Mail, edited the news site The Stirrer, and published the book Where's The Money Gone? The Battle For The Soul Of English Football.
In this episode
The centre of this one is Adrian's father, a German Jewish boy put on a boat to Harwich weeks before war broke out, one of only two from the whole extended family to survive the Holocaust. That inheritance shapes a wider talk about migration then and now, and why he wears the label son of a refugee with pride. It loosens up too, into the punk DIY spirit behind his teenage band and a proper argument about football, West Brom and where all the money in the game has gone.Find out more: Wikipedia Byline Times
Chapter markers are not available for this episode.
Transcript
This transcript is auto-generated and may contain errors. Tap a timestamp to jump the video.
A matter of weeks before the outbreak ofWorld War IIwhen my dad at that time was 13,he was put on a boat with his brother,the only people who survived from theentire extended family. I listened to alot of music and I wanted to be in aband and I had a year really of tryingto make it with my band LowdownInternational. One of the big drivers ofmy life was that punk had a DIY ethic,this sense of you don't have to wait forthe man to do it for you.Hello there. Welcome to our lives, ourstories with me Carl Chinn. And todayI'm chuffed to welcome somebody whomI've admired for his broadcasting work,
his football commentaries and much morebesides for many years. He is AdrianGoldberg. Adrian, thanks for joining metoday. How are you Chinn? How good is itto be here with you? I've been pesteringyou for years.>> You have. To do a podcast. Finally, herewe are doing one as well. So, brilliant.We've got to talk about the football cuzit's very important to you, not onlyyour team West Bromwich Albion, but alsoabout the money in football. I want totalk with you about your work inbroadcasting, Radio 4, etc. But first ofall, can we have a chat about yourbackground because there's a remarkable,in fact much more than the wordremarkable can convey, story about yourdad in particular, isn't there? Yeah,
well both my parents are migrants toBirmingham and I'm very mindful of thatin these times when there's a lot ofanti-migrant sentiment and a lot of thestuff that was around in the 70s and80s, a lot of the nasty stuff, a lot ofthe racist stuff has kind of resurfacedin a different form. So, I'd put on mysocial media handle son of a refugee andI'm proud of that fact and I'm proud tobelong to a country, the United Kingdom,that has encouraged so many migrants tosettle here, whether refugees like mydad, whether economic migrants like mymom. That's part of what makes us whatwe are here in the UK and it's partespecially of what makes us what we arehere in Birmingham and the West
Midlands. So, my dad was a German Jewishrefugee. He grew up in a little towncalled Ratibor as it was then known,Silesia on the eastern side of Germanyin Prussia. And in fact in the post-warsettlement, it was then handed to Polandand it's now Racibórz, completelydifferent town. But I have been backthere which is quite interesting. Whenhe was about 13,the Nazis had come to power. It wasclear that war was about to beginand there was this amazing programcalled Kindertransportand it was amazing to an extent. I mean,it reflects a kind of anti-Semitism at
the time I think in the UKthat people were allowed to send theirchildren to this country if there was asponsor, a guardian who would look afterthem. But the adults weren't allowed tocome. So, it was an incredibly generousgestureby the UKto allow my father to come, but alsolike many other countries in the world,there was also that generosity was lacedwith anti-Semitism cuz they didn't wantthe adults. Anyway, the fortunate thingis for my dad was that inJune 1939,we're talking, yeah, a matter of weeksbefore the outbreak of World War II whenmy dad at that time was 13,
he was put on a boat and came to the UK,came to Harwich with his brother.And those two, my dad Rudy and hisbrother Werner, were pretty much theonly people who survived from the entireextended family. My dad's parents, hisgranddad, uncles, aunts, cousins, allkilled in the Holocaust. Did your dadRudy talk to you about his life inGermany before and during the Naziterror? Yeah, and I think perhapsbecause I was the youngest of four, I'vegot two older sisters and an olderbrother who's now sadly passed away. So,
as the youngest of four, I think therehad been a gap of time between my dad'sexperience and thenbeing able to process that and talkabout it. So, I think by the time I wasyoungand and sort of coming to anunderstanding of what had happened, hespoke about it with me perhaps more thanhe had done with my older siblings, buthe talked about his dad being takenaway, probably in about, I'd say, 1933,34, early concentration camps that werenot or work camps that were not deathcamps at that stage. But his dadcoming back and had and had his headshaved. I mean, the irony of all this, I
should say Carl, two ironies really, wasthat he said that they were very muchsecular Jews. I mean, they they wereJewish people by heritage, but they werenot people whowerededicatedsynagogue goers. You know, my dad saidthey might gone once or twice over theyears. You know, they were not regularattenders.You know, he had to say his prayers inHebrew and when he came to Birmingham,he ended up being a member of, but againnot a a devoted attender of the SingersHill Synagogue. So, he knew how to readhis his prayers in Hebrew. So, he'd havethat level of Jewish education, but theywere not religious Jews. They were justJews by heritage. So, that was one irony
really that, you know, although hiswider family was put to death for beingJewish,that was a racial identity as much as areligious identity. But the other ironyis that both hisfather and grandfatherhad fought for either Germany or Prussiain conflictbefore World War II. Now, truthfully, Idon't know the full detail of that andI'd love to find out more and I'm intendto find out more.But I've got a picture of my dad in mygranddad in Germansoldier's uniform sitting on a chairvery much like this one with hisfather standing behind him also with a amilitary uniform on. So, they would have
fought for their country, but whenHitler came to power, that wasn't goodenough for them and sadly they were bothput to death. So, my dad spoke aboutthat and he spoke to meabout Kristallnacht. I recorded aninterview with my dad. I mean,Kristallnacht in this town of Racibórz,he said thatby the time Kristallnacht happened,they they he had beenforced to stop going to school. He'dgone to a a Christian school,but he was no longer allowed to go toschool. He said when he was younger,he had never experienced any issues withhis Jewish background, but then as hegot older and as the Nazis came to powerand consolidated power, then
increasingly that became an issue withschoolmates, friends who had beenvery close to him started shunning him.There was a perception thatthis he was sort of bad to know, youknow, it was it was not a good thing.So, there was there was this kind ofsense of rising menaceand he he had and his his dad his dadand his mom ran a little pub, a waysideinn on the outskirts of Racibórz, butthey'd been forced to sell up as manyJewish businesses had been forced to doto sell up and move in with my dad'sgrandparents. But he he told me aboutremembering seeing a mob chasing a womanor following a woman, a Jewish womanvery closely on Kristallnacht and
chanting at her and being aggressivetowards her. This was the night whenthey smashed the windows, the Nazis, ofJewish homes, Jewish businesses thatwere left and and brought terror to theJewish people.>> Yeah, it was the it I suppose it was theturning point in the persecution of Jewsin Germany in that from Kristallnachtonwards, Kristallnacht was the nighton which it became clear that if youwere a Jew in Germany, as long as theNazis were in power, you would not besafe. Life would not go back to how itwas before. So, and synagogues wereburned. The synagogue in Racibórz wherethey lived was burnt on this night. Infact, it was quite eerie. I went back to
Racibórz for a radio program andactually stood on the site where thesynagogue had been and it was it wassuch a strange feeling and it's now justa patch of open land.But it was really reallystrange [clears throat]to stand there. But my dad had spokenabout that. He'd spoken as well aboutgoing to the local train station everyday when his father had been taken away.His father had essentially been roundedup in one of these kind ofpre-warkind of pogroms I suppose.>> What's a pogrom? And he'd been takenaway and this is when he came back hisfather with shaven hair andby this time he hadn't beenwasn't allowed to go to school because
he was Jewish. So, he just used to godown to the train station and wait everyday for his dad to come back for a fewdays and his dad did come back. He saidhis father never really spokeabout what had happened, but it wasclear that there was this sense ofgrowing menace as 1939approached. And you said that your dadremembered this woman, Jewish woman inthe street.>> Yes. What happened?>> She was she was being kind of pursueddown the street by a mob. From what mydad said, kind of more like walkingafter her, chanting after her. I don'tknow what words were used, but thensuddenly a door opened in a an apartmentblock and it was as though he saidsomebody pulled her inside and pulledher off the street. Thankfully, he
didn't see anything happening to her,but again, if you're a young Jewish kidwatching a Jewish woman being followeddown the street and a group chantingafter her, that's pretty pretty menacingand you know, it would No, that fill youwith fear. How did your dad find out orhis mom and dad find out about theKindertransport?I don't know how that came about, but Iguess that just would have been part ofthe conversation in German life andJewish life and English life at thetime. So, I don't know how they foundout about that. And I remember he talkedabout I'm pretty sure he went toHamburg. So, you Hamburg's a long way>> Way. from where they were.>> southeast up to the north.
>> Yeah, and you know, being put on thetrain and kind of saying goodbye to hisparents. He he didn't talk with greatemotion about that, but I mean, as aparent myself, can you imagine that?Putting your kids, you know, my my dadwas 13.His younger brother Werner was 11 atthat time. I mean,the more the older I get,the you know, as a kid you just hearthis as a story. The older I get, themore emotional I get>> Yes, I understand.>> talking about that. Just putting yourkids on a train going off to who knowswhere.You know, you know they're going toEngland. Who to? What are they going toWhat What's life going to be like inEngland? And then hewas put on theput on the train.
They go to Hamburg, go from Rattibor, Iguess, to to Hamburg, then get put on aship to Harwich.And then they're put in a a receptioncenter. And then I think one of thegreatest sadnesses of my dad's lifewas that because he was 13 coming up to14 at that point, which was the age atwhich people left school.>> Yeah, you became a man at that age.>> Indeed. And you know, my dad was quite aan educated man. He was a a learned manand yeah, I suppose he had the capacityto do something quite academic, quiteintellectual with his life. But he wasput to work straight away and separatedby several hundred miles>> Oh, no. from his brother, Werner. So,Werner was adopted by
a lady called Gladys and her husbandwhose name I sadly can't remember inSouthampton.And he went on to become atown architect in Guildford.And that a you know, a very nice life,really. I'm No doubt he too was scarredby the childhood experience. My dad wasput to work on a farm in ruralDerbyshire.And I I can't imagine how that must havebeen. I mean, you're 13 coming up to 14.And I know in those days there wasprobably an expectation, as you say,people were assumed to be a man at thatage. So, there was a differentpsychology, but even so,>> I know. you've just been sent away fromyour parents and then you've got
hundreds of miles between youand your brother. Andhe the At least there was supervision bythe Red Cross.And they would check in on theKindertransport children and say, "Howare you doing?" And I think he made itknown that he wasn't particularly happy.I don't think he was particularly welltreated in this farm in Derbyshire. I'mnot suggesting he was abused in any way,but it it was just a bit and you know,England by this day which was at warwith Germany. As far as they wereconcerned, he was a German. Yeah. So, Idon't I don't think he was treated withmuch kindness.>> theya German, as you said that the Jewishpeoplealways saw themselves as Germans>> Yes.
>> first.>> Yes. And Jewish, that's our part of ouridentity, but we're Germans. Yes. Yeah,and I think for my dad and his familybecause they were secular Jews, really,I mean, [clears throat]there would have been no distinction intheir mind frombeing German and Jewish. You know, thatThat was where, as far as I know,generations of their family had lived.It was you know, it was a such aObviously, Nazism is such a warpedideology. One thing that struck me iscompared to mostfamilies who hadatrace their beginnings in England tosomebody like your father who had to
flee as a child,they didn't have any photographs.You have got a photo of your granddadYes.>> and your dad. That must be quite rare,Adrian.I think one of the thingswas that I think my dad's parents werequite well-to-do. They weren't loaded,but they ran this wayside inn and Ithink that was a reasonably decentbusiness at the time and I thinkthey even made I've seen an advert froma local newspapermaybe from the1920s and they made a kind of liquor, aliqueur>> Yes. that had gold in it.>> Really?>> And I think there was a thing Yeah,obviously not real gold. But Goldflakes. That was Yeah, it was a kind ofa a thing and I and I think my dad used
to talk about they would go out and alsoprovide alcohol, take it out tomore remote areas in the countrysidearound there. My dad sitting on a ponyand trap going out with his dad andhaving these days out and delivering thethe alcohol. You know, so there werethere were some goodmemoriesalbeit, you know, all clouded bysadness. He had a a favorite aunt, alady called Aunt Jenny andlast year I set up a record label inhonor of Aunt Jenny because she was thefun aunt and my dad talked about howthey would go to the riversideand Aunt Jenny would come or he would goand see her in Berlin, but she was theaunt who'd put you on her shoulders and
then and she'd wade into the river andhe you know, she'd So, I'm going tothrow you in the water now andtease tease the kids. You know, therewere good memories there. But as yousay, yeah, they had photographs which Ithink perhaps reflects on the fact thatthey were reasonably well-to-do andcould pose for these. But for you tohave a visual record,>> Yeah. Yeah. that's so important, isn'tit, Adrian? Yeah. Yeah, well, it's greatcuz I can show it to my kids now, youknow, and it's part of their heritage,part of their story and part of theirhistory. How did your dad come toBirmingham then? So, my dad at the endof the war was in the Royal Hampshires.So, played his part in the war. He wasan interpreter at the end of the war. Idon't know what the Royal Hampshires got
up to. He talked about going to Italywith the Royal Hampshires. Again, I I'dreally like to interrogate that a littlebit what he actually did in the war. Buthe's It was only right at the end of itcuz of his relatively young age. Andthen after the war,he heI think the the Red Red Cross hadmanaged to get him a jobumon a farm in Hampshire so he could becloser to his brother. Yes.>> in that area then, in the post-war era,Birmingham was a boom town, an absoluteboom town. It was the centerof manufacturing in what was still thenseen as this great global empire. Yeah.So, he came to Birmingham to work in the
factories and I think bear in mind he'dhad the experience of being shifted outof Germany. He'd then, you know, likeeverybody else, been through theexperience of six years of war. So,although I said he's quite an educatedand kind of a learned man, I think atthat stage,you know, he was a he was aa drift in the world of work and heneeded to earn a living. So, he justcame and worked in a factory. He workedat BSA, Birmingham Small Arms, which iswhere he met my mom. Right. So,[laughter] tell us about your mom. Whatwas her name? So, my mom, Kitty,was from Cork and she grew up in a verypoor family. I don't think they werepoor
to start with, but sadly her mom was analcoholic.And my mom was often sort of kept offschool to try and look after the houseand cook tea for the dad and all thatstuff. And I think uh my grandfather, mymom's my maternal grandfather,was quite a proper man. He worked for anundertaker's firm and you know, he hadto have dinner on the table at a certaintime. Obviously, a man of his generationand and of his time.But I think what wealth the family hadsadly wasdrunk away in Cadden's, which was thelocal bar, the bar at the end of thestreet, 98 Streetin Cork, which I've been to and youknow, kind of these very low slung
buildings, very basic.And like a lot of Irish people in thepost-war era, you Ireland obviously wasthenitdevastatingly poor, wasn't it? And shecame over to England and with a with asome of her sisters came over to the UK.Some went off to the United States. Itwas It was an era of massive emigrationfrom Ireland and she got a jobat the BSA as well, which is where shemet my dad. It's a fascinating story,Adrian. Yeah, well, it's I know, to meit's just my parents, you know,but you know, I but I do II suppose coming from Birmingham, which
is a city of migration,I I you know, I'm proud of that. I'm I'mproud of Birmingham being a city ofmigration, a place where people havecome to and made their lives and wherefor all the many differences that peopleunderstandably have,that people broadly get along actually.And I think that you know, a Birminghamand I identity, unlike a lot ofother identities, is not one where thatrelies on having to have been here forhundreds of years previously. I thinkthat it's a place where people can comeand feel it is their home.If they it's a for me it's like if youwant to be a Brummie,you can be a Brummie.
>> you're saying that. Well, I find it'sit's interesting you're saying thatbecause yesterday as part of my role asa deputy lieutenant, I spoke at acitizenship ceremony and I said to thethe new citizens of our country and ourcity, "My family been here for 250years. It doesn't make me more of aBrummie than you." Yeah. Yeah. Well,that's a lovely that's a lovelysentiment and and you know, I'm glad youknow, that people are being told that. Ithink it's a really a really good and aand a positive thing cuz of course thereare people with incredible historieslike yours and we should celebrate thosetoo.And it's not an either or, is it? It'sjust it's about being inclusive. One ofthe things I said yesterday was thatlet's all be proud of who we aredifferently, but let's all be proud ofwho we are collectively. Yes. Yeah. And
I think a lot of that has beenforgotten, hasn't it? Over over yearswhen identity politics has become somuch to the fore and of course there areidentities that have beenlooked down upon, that have beenforgotten and it's understandable thatpeople want to kind of reclaim thoseidentities and say "Well, don't forgetabout my history. Don't forget about myhistory." That's important, butultimately if we can't allow that andyou've used this word to me in the past,we can't allow that to atomize us.>> No. No. That's all important,but overall the more important thing isthe thing that binds us together, thecollective identity. So, talking ofidentity, you've got a secular Jewish
dad.Was your mom Catholic? Obviously>> [laughter]>> from Cork. Although there areProtestants in There are. In fact, therewere also uh I think there was aGoldberg family in Cork.>> Really?>> I think there was a a Jewish family whowhen the when Jews were kicked outperhaps of England or kicked out ofother Irish cities,theyand Ithis may just be fantasy. Now, you'vegot to check this out, but I think therewere a Goldberg family who went to Corkand were admitted to the cityon the basis of you know, why not? Youyou haven't done us any harm. He went onto prosperand he then
very generously endowed the city of Corkwith buildings and there was a kind ofa kind of a connection there between asmall Jewish community. So, was your momreligious? My mom was very religious.She was a devout Catholic. So, before mymom and dad could get married,>> Yeah. my dad had to go and meet thebishopand signa promisethat my mom would be allowed to bring usup as Catholics. Now, I know thatfeeling very well cuz my wife Kay isCatholic.I didn't have to meet the Bishop ofDublin, but Kay's priest got in touchwith the bishop and I had to signas a member of the Church of England
that I would bring the children>> Very suspect. I'm not>> [laughter]>> I think this was the Bishop ofBirmingham or the Archbishop. I I'm notsure exactly, but my dad had to go andsee a very senior priest and pledge andpledge in writing to to bring to allowmy mom to bring us up as Catholics,which she did to the best of herability, but itwe werewe so we grew up in Northfield on thefurthest edges of Northfield reallywhere it almost becomes Bartley Green.>> Yeah. Yeah.>> And The edge of the known world for therest>> The edge of the known world it is and Imention that becausethere was no I mean every everywhere inBirmingham there's an Irish community,you know, but we weren't embedded in theway that if you if you ran a place like
>> Sparkhill. Yeah, exactly. There wasthere was there was there were peoplefrom all sorts of places there. So, wedid I didn't and my and my mom, althoughshe was very proud of her Irish rootsand never sought to hide them, both sheand my dad took the view that we're herenow and they were in they were keen forus to for one of a better wordassimilate.So,and also given the times that we grew upin, you know, I was coming of age sortof in the mid to late 70s. So, I I'mafraid sorry, Mom. I threw off myCatholicism.Uhone of my sisters is still you know, achurch goer and she gives communion topeople who are not able to go to church,
you know, so she's kind of kept thethread. A bit like my Jewish identityand the German part of that identity aswell, by the way. And you know, I kindofmaybe you want to talk about this, Idon't know, but I think that the theGerman-ness is often forgotten in this,but I'll I'll I'll tell you what I meanby this in a minute. But all I was goingto say was that the German-ness, theJewish-ness, the Irish-ness, theCatholic-ness, I'd never want to disownany of those as my heritage, but I'mactually not any of those things, youknow, I'm I'm me and and I I take thatattitude. I think I try and take thatattitude into all my conversations andall my dealings with other people. Youmay be badged by society as this, this,
this and this. You are you and everybodydeserves to be treated as an individual.But the to go back to the German-ness, Imentioned that becauseI became aware particularly after Brexitthat I could reclaim my German passport,uh reclaim my German nationality. Now,I I don't you know, for me it probablydoesn't make much difference, but for mykids who then are therefore eligible forGerman nationality as well as British.I'm not renouncing>> German nationality.>> British, yeah.Uh I applied for and have got Germannationality andI also think in terms of putting rightthe wrongs of history as much as you
can,that's really important because althoughHitler said and defined that that my mydad and his brother and their familywere Jews and defined them in thatnarrow way, they were Jews.They were Germans. They were everybodyas much Germanas everybody else. A heathen, a pagan.>> Yeah, and and andand I and from my point of view, youknow, I it's like an up yours to Hitlerto claim my German nationality.>> put my two fingers up there in supportof me towards [laughter]towards him. What about your school? Didyour mom's did she send you to Catholicschools? She did, yeah. So, I went toSt. Bridget's in Northfield and um yeah,I mean, it was just a I think a bog
standard primary school in Birmingham. Idon't have any strong feelings for oragainst uhthat school. It was run by strict nuns,which I think people who weren't aroundin the 60s and 70s will know that whatstrict nuns were like andsometimes got rapped over the knuckleswith a ruler for doing not very much,you know, quite a strong sense of ofdiscipline.But secondary school, I'd been on oneoccasion I mentioned my brother whosadly no longer with us. He was 11 yearsolder than me.Uh my brother John, I remember going toseethe headmaster of his school, which wasKing's Norton Grammar School,and I remember sitting on the bus with
me mom and riding down Northfield Roadand all these lovely trees that were inbloom at the time and going into thisgorgeous school, wood paneled, theteachers still wore mortarboards andthese black cloaks. I mean, this wouldhave beensometime in the early 70s.It was another world and I'd already gota taste for books like Tom Brown'sSchool Days and Just Williamand I felt like I was walking into thisfictional world that I'd seen describedwas actually real. this school and thenMom was going said "I've got to talkabout your brother John." Anyway, I fellin love with this place. I I just
thought this is where I want to come.What I didn't know at the time was thatmy mom had gone to see the headmaster toexpel my brother.>> Oh my. [laughter]So, my brother was a bit of a bad ladand he was biffed out of school, but I'dalready fallen in love with this placewith King's Norton Boys School. So, mymom dearly wanted me to go to Tommies,St. Thomas Aquinas, which was the thekind of the go-to secondary school ifyou passed your 11 plus, which was stilla thing in Birmingham at that time.But there were two things againstTommies. One, I'd fallen in love withKing's Norton School, the place. Two,Tommies didn't play football, playedrugby. Andone of the bizarre features of
Birmingham schools at that time was thatloads of the secondary schools, eventhough rugby union or rugby league werenot really a thing in Birmingham,loads of the schools played rugby.Shenley Court, which is my other localschool,they played rugby rather than football.I was at Moseley Grammar, we playedrugby. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I'm glad I didnow cuz it gave me another game to beat.I was never I was never Yeah, maybe. Iwas never going to go to a school thatplayed rugby. I was never going to go toa school that didn't play football. So,talking of football, how did a kid fromthe edge of Birmingham on the deepsouthwest of Birminghamcome to support the Albion?>> Yeah. Well, that's a good question and Iwas
for a few years, Carl, I was a floatingvoter and we didn't have football in ourfamily. So, neither me mom or dad wasinto football. Me dad to his creditwould take me sometimes. He often workedon Saturday, so it wasn't easy for him,but he had no he had no love offootball. So, I danced aroundAlbion, Blues, Villa, even Wolves for atime. Went to games with my mate PeteShelley, you know.The the point at which a team stuck withme was when I went in about 1975.I was quite new to secondary school withmy mate Ian Busby, who was a big Baggiesfan.
And I think I'd only been to Albion onceat this occasion prior to this in about1972, when I was it was just too youngreally to take much in. But I stood inthe Bromwich Road with Ian Busby.And Albion were then in the seconddivision, in the Championship, and theywere rubbish. And there was a greatgallows humor about the place. It was avery down-to-earth.It probably in a way because it was alittle bitquieterthan say going to Villa Park or St.Andrew's,it just felt a little bit quirky and alittle bit individual. And from where Ilived geographically, it wasn't thatfar, you know, if you as the crow flies.I to be truthfully, I think on the the
block of flats where I grew up, I thinkI only ever knew one other Albion fan.But it wason that day I kind of fell in love withit really. And I and I kind of nailed mycolors to the Albion on that day inabout October 1975.And here we are 51 years later. It'sinteresting because you're able tochoose. I had no choice.>> Yes.And my kids don't have any choice.That's>> [laughter]>> the first match I seen, I was nine andwe lost 6-2 at home to Chelsea and gotrelegated in that year.>> [laughter]>> You're like me, Adrian. Football is morethan just watching the game. It'sour identity,our belonging. It's part of ourfamilies. Yes, it is. And what I will
say is that maybe because I've got thatkind of slightly detached background.Although I love the Albion and theAlbion are my club, maybe I cansometimes view it with a bit moredetachment than people. But one of thejoys of my life is that I've taken allthree of my daughters to the Albion andthey've all come and had season ticketsat different times. But my youngestGracie, who is 11, really soaks it upand she absorbs it and it's, you[snorts] know, it'sI I'll probably won't pass on much to mykids. But if I can pass on a love of theAlbion, but also a love of football,yeah. That that would be something I'dbe proud of cuz I think football's agreat game. It's aWhoever you support, it's a brilliantgame and I'll I'll break bread withsupporters of any club. I think, you
know, there is a a passion and a unity.We all have the same stories. We allhave the good days and the bad days.They may, you know, vary depending onthe level you're at, but we all broadlyhave the same experience.>> "Do you enjoy going down to matches? Doyou enjoy it?" I went, "You don't enjoyfootball.>> [laughter]>> It's heartbreak. Even when you'rewinning, your heart's going Well, look,you know, as we record this, I'm freshfrom seeing Albion losing 5-0at home last night from a team below usin the league, one of the worstperformancesin that 51 years that I've ever seen atthe Hawthorns.In 2 days time they're playing away atDerby. I'll be there.>> [laughter]
>> We're going to go back to the footballlater because you've become a reallyinsightful,thoughtful, and analytical commentatoron the state of the professional game.But if I can take you back to King'sNorton Grammar, you got there?>> Yes. Did you love it?I went up and down in my school career,truthfully. I mean, I think I was a bitof a lost young man at times. I think,you know, in my second year at King'sNorton,in the This was in the days when theyused to do school rankings.You know, they'd put you what positiondid you come in the class?And in the second year at my school,what would now be year eight,I came 28th out of 30.
You know, I was I was I was Hormones arekicking in.You know, I don't know. I was I had aterrible year and umI I remember kind of scribbling out the28 and trying totrying to persuade my parents that I'dcome 18th, which I thought was at least,you know, not great, but not as terribleas 28th would be.>> It was more like halfway down, you meanto say? Well, yeah, you know, it's lowermid-table. It's all right. I mean,II think I don't I don't quite know whatlies behind this girl, but I had, youknow, I was quite troubled at times. Ihad a whole thing as a school kid. Iremembernot eating my sandwiches, maybe havingit as I look back on it now, maybehaving an eating disorder. I've never
spoken about this before, by the way, inpublic, you know, butin junior school,I would not eat my sandwiches. I don'tknow why I wouldn't eat my sandwiches.Used to take them home and put them in acupboardby the side of the bed. And then everynow and again, when Mom and Dad weren'tin or when they weren't looking, I'dtake them to the chute in the flatswhere we were and chuck them down thechute. And um Which went to the wherethe dustbin area Yeah, yeah, yeah. Andone time,I think I got found out by the schooland they told me mom.Andumthere was a whole to-do about and Iinvented then. I So then you get caughtup, you know, one lie leads to another.
Um why have youYou know, why did you do this? Iremember my mom interrogating them. Mymom, you know, verybulldog with a, you know, sort of Oh,you have not eaten, son. Yeah, yeah,what's what's the what's the crack? AndI just said, "Well,oh, are you being bullied? Are you beingbullied?" And "No, I'm not being Are youbeing bullied? Are you?" "All right, I'mbeing bullied." "Who's bullying you?"You know,>> [laughter]>> yeah, yeah, I know, I know, I know. Andthen she I remember her coming to theschool and going around every classroomtrying to identify the bully. Theimaginary Yeah, the imaginary bully. SoI think as a kid, II mean, there were things like So mymom, because my dad only ever did kindof manual factory jobs, he he ran
You know, he he sort of be somebody inthe warehouse. You know, so not not kindof basic track work. And he'd sometimesbe white-collar in the factories that heworked, but not earning very much, kindof low-grade white-collar worker.And again, that's maybe a distinctionthat's gone these days, but it matteredto him and to my mom. He used to wear atie to go to work and he couldsometimes, this was a a big company inBirmingham called Newman Tonks, yes, whowere based aroundI suppose Newtown Aston area, which madedoor fastenings and so on.Um you know, very classic kind of WestMidlands kind of metal bashing company.Um but he never earned much, so my mom
had to go to work for a few hours a day.She used to work at various jobs, butshe mostly at the Royal Orthopedic andshe'd serve up dinners and she was adomestic, did domestic work at the RoyalOrthopedic. But that meant her going outof school out of homeat the time when I'd come home fromschool. And I think, you know,as a grown-up, I understand why she didit cuz we would have we wouldn't havebeen able to go on holiday or have newshoes. But I think as a kid, I resentedthat, I think. I think that must haveplayed messed with my head cuz it feltlike some kind of rejection that I'd gethome and me mom wasn't there and I'dhave to get me dinner out the oven. Andall that sort of stuff.>> And with some your your siblings beingso much older than you. Yeah, yeah,yeah. So I was by that stage I'd mostly
be there,you know, certainly when I was gettinginto my teenage years, on my own, yeah.So it was it was strange. SoYeah, I was probably a bit, you know,there was stuff going on in there. Alittle bit lonely. Yeah, yeah, yeah,yeah, maybe. But but also feeling a bitpushed away as well, you know, so Didthe Albion start to fill that void?Possibly, yeah, yeah. Well, I mean, youknow, the classicthings that have identity in football isdefinitely one. Football and music.>> Yeah. You know, so Albion was becamemassive and I used to go with a a ladnot with Ian Busby, the lad who'd takenme originally, but another guy atschool, Rob Crawford. Um Rob and I usedto go and we were big buddies. And then
I came into another group of people. SoYeah. you know, the people have changed,but the club has remained the same.But but yeah, so there was football, butthen sort of punk rock Oh, no, let's geton to that.What stage, what age were you when punkrock started? So I was 15 when punkreally started kicking in in '77. Right.Um andI'd Ikind of been to one concert, been to thegreat Four Tops with my sister. Theywere brilliant. And my my older sisterswere both into soul music, so Ideveloped a love of soul music throughmy sisters. My brother had been intomore like Bob Dylan. Yeah. But I'd neverreally I never really liked noisy rock
music. That that had not been any partof ourfamily music at home. And me mom hadliked sort of Irish music and, you know,music of the musicals and all that sortof stuff. And then partly the storyabout punk, you know, which is abouttelling authority where to get off.>> Yeah, yeah. You know, when you're ateenager, what you know, it wasrebellious. And and there was a big partof it that I just enjoyed the therebelliousness of it just for its ownsake. Cuz what teenager doesn't want torebel? Um so there was a bit of that. UmAlso, for me, the best punk music,although it was quite noisy,they would all You know, you think of aband like the Buzzcocks, they were alsogreat pop songs. And I always had a bitof a sweet ear. So,
you know, whereas I didn't really lovekind of hard crashing rock music likeLed Zeppelin, it was all a bitYeah, yeah,you know, punk had a bit more of a sweetedge to it as well as being noisy. So, Ijust started going I I I wrote to a bandum a band called Chelsea and um I boughttheir one of their early singles called"The Right to Work" and they only playeduhnightclubs Barbarella's in Birmingham.And I was not fair, you know, I'mI'm can't get in the club. And uh thethe lead singer Gene October howexciting wrote back to me and said, "Oh,don't worry about it. We are playingBarbarella's again, but if you turn up
at 5:00>> Oh. and help us in with the gear." So, Iwas 15 at this time. "You help us inwith the gear, um we'll we'll let you inwith us." And now there was a couple ofbadges free badges with it as well. Andso, I went and helped him in and umand then I thought, "Oh, I could dothis. Whoever comes to town." So, I didthat when I did that with The Clash. Idid that with The Adverts. I did it withThe Angelic Upstarts. And it was a greatway to kind of get to meet bands and getin free. Uh it did mean you were thereabout 8 hours before the gig started,but I don't I don't look back at it now.Uh I think, "Oh, what what my parents upto?">> just wondering what your dad did withyour mom's fish. Well, I think I think
sometimes [snorts]this was true, by the way. Sometimesthis was true. I would say, um"I'm going with a mate." Yeah. And theyyou know, they knew one or two of mymates from school. So, I might say, "I'mgoing with a mate." And sometimes I wasand sometimes I wasn't.>> [laughter]>> But I mean, in those days Birmingham hadnight buses through the week.>> Yes. And you could>> which didn't run the full route.>> No. So, I used to get So, by this timearound this time we moved to from sortof one sort of overspill area, which wasNorthfield, this block of flats on theedge of Northfield. We moved to DruidsHeath. Yeah.>> Yeah. Also, another sort of overspillestate really right on the edge of town,but Druids Heath was really importantfor me
because it was just up the road fromMoseley. One bus ride from Moseley,which had a great gig scene at the agewhen I was starting to get into gigs.But to go back to the the the nightbuses, so I I lived the buses would stopat the Maypole. Yes. And that'd be likea 20-minute walk.I was like, "Well, why?" You know, cuzthe bus the bus driver would literallyjust sit there for half an hour beforeturning around and going back the otherway. Why did just two more stops, mate,you know?>> And we all had to get a bus in Philipfor the last [laughter] the that latenight buses. Oh, yeah. Well, I used Iremember you know, having to walk and beyou know, being a kid, you know, thiswas thethe sort of mid-to-late '70s and being abit terrified of walking through all thetower blocks and you know, looking a bitlike a punk when punks were being set
upon, you know. Thankfully, nothing everhappened to me, but it was a bit scary.Um It It's interesting again uh I'm thatbit older than you. 1978 me and Kay weremarried.We couldn't stand punk. You know, wewere soul kids. I was a reggae kid aswell. Do you know what I mean?And it's that 5-6 year difference makesa big difference at that age, doesn'tit?>> Yeah. Oh, absolutely. I mean, even 2years at that age makes a massivedifference, doesn't it, in terms of whatyou like? But sort of punk was mydoorway really to a kind of a a widerworld of music and alternative culture.>> Yes. And I said, you know, whatever ageit was, I suspect I would have lookedfor it and and found that, but but punkwas a very easy door to go through. Anduh
I started then going to what you know,thenthis this idea, which I think is reallybeen so important in my life, one of thebig drivers of my life, was that punkhad a DIY ethic. Right.>> So, at the center of punk was this senseof you don't have to wait for the man todo it for you. You don't have to get arecord label to release a record. So,that was one of the great things aboutpunk. The Buzzcocks I think started itand discovered, you know, you canactually just go to a record pressingplant. You don't need to be Sony or EMI.You can if you've got enough money, youcan say to this record presser, "Can Ihave a thousand pressed off?" And umthat then became a massive boom in punk
music was people creating their ownrecords, creating their own littlerecord labels. Andas I've as I've kind of tried in my wayto carry the spirit of punk through mylife, that idea that you don't needsomebody else. You know, that you don'tneed somebody to validate what you'redoing. And the fact that you're doingvalidates it. And you know, I stillcarry you know, there's kind of a snoband a purist in me about it in that ifyou know, if I've got the choice betweenseeing a covers band or a band I'venever heard of playing their own music,I'll always go and see the the band I'venever heard of playing their own musicbecause it's inherently more valid for
me that you're playing your own thing.Even ifobjectively, it's not very good, it'syours.>> Yeah. And so, that powered me throughreally. That's kind of why I created afootball fanzine in the mid-'80s whenpeople weren't doing that kind of thing.And I just thought, "Yeah, let's umyeah, well, it's always it's alwaysdriven me that idea that you can dostuff yourself.Was it through thatlove of punk and music in general, butparticularly punk, that led you intowriting, into journalism, intobroadcasting?>> I suppose so. I mean, Iagain, I probably I I think I would havedone that anyway, but but sort of one ofthe big features of the punk scene wasfanzines, which was people doing it for
themselves. So, there were the existingmusic papers like Sounds, the NME andMelody Maker, but there was a reallythriving scene of people just makingtheir own magazines and I thought thatwas so exciting. So, I remember orderingonline a copy of a a punk magazine, thethe kind of the classic punk fanzinecalled Sniffin' Glue.But then there was [snorts] a a localone called 021 um when Birmingham's postthe phone phone number was 021 not 0121.There was another one called The Soundof Spaghetti.And um there was I remember anotherlocal-ish one, Midlands one called DeadYampy. Andso, I'd read these and it what But
again, it definitely was part of thatethic of you don't need somebody else todo it for you. You can do it yourself.And I'd go to gigs and these people likeme would be selling fanzines. And it itwas definitely, "Well, if they can doit, can't I do it? You know, I can doit, too." And you did do it.>> And I did do it, yeah. Not not withmusic, but by the mid-'80s I was stillmassively into music.Football had got to such a state.Obviously, there was a lot ofhooliganism, a lot of football violence.Uh hooliganism kind of makes it soundlike larking around. There was someserious violence at football.But also, there were some seriously badactors operating in the boardrooms of
football clubs.>> And people who had no regard for thetradition, the heritage, the value tocommunity of football. So,the mainstream press was dealing withthehooligan side of it. That you know, Iwas a fan. That was you know, I Icouldn't solve that.But I it seemed to me that the otherside of it, the the machinations at thetop of the game, the people who ownedclubs, but not for the best of reasons,who was tackling them? So, that was whywith my mate Steve Beauchamp, who sadlypassed away now, my mate Sid Collins andmy then girlfriend Sally Cooper, youknow, I have to say sort of led by me,decided we've got to do something aboutthis and taking the the template of punk
fanzines, we put that intofootball and said, "Right, let's createthis football magazine.">> And what was it called?>> It's called Off the Ball.>> Off the Ball.>> Off the Ball, yeah. Yeah.>> And it wasn't just about the Albion, wasit?>> No, no, it was a general footballfanzine. In fact, at those times I Imean, Albion were going through a apretty rocky patch on the pitch, butthey were mostly run by good people whojust didn't run it very well. But therewere, you know, bad actors in football,people like David Bulstrode who wantedto merge Fulham and Queen's ParkRangers, two very distinct and proudclubs in West London. People like RobertMaxwell, you know, the absolute roguethat Robert Maxwell was and he ownedOxford United and he tried to merge them
with Reading, creating the Thames ValleyRoyals. And he also had an interest inDerby County. So, and it seemed that Imean, locally here in the West Midlands,there were people like Ken Wheldon, whowas an owner of Birmingham City, theowner of Birmingham City, but who alsothenby hook or by crook took over Walsalland wanted to move Walsall to come andplay at St. Andrew's.So, he was a scrap metal dealer and apro interest in property. You know, youdidn't have tobe too clever to work out what might begoing on.We've jumped quickly from '77punk 15-year-old into the mid-'80s. Whatdid you do when you left school? Well,
cuz me mom wanted me to get a properjob, didn't she? I remember my mom goingto careers once, by the way. You know,they had careers advisers. And uh me momsaid, "When you go in there." I mean,this again is the thing of people thatyou know, nobody in our family had beento university.You don't know the careersofficer is a person of authority thatyou know, your parents who don't knowvery much just cuz they've never been inthat situation themselves assume yourcareers officer has got a big say inwhat happens to your life. So, go to thecareers officer and me mom says,"Whatever you do, just tell him you wantto be a manager." Right. Yeah. Iremember going to see the careersofficer cuz my mom was terrified that Iwould end up
working in a factory on the line cuzthat's what, you know, most kids fromwhere I grew up ended up doing. And, youknow, there's no nothing wrong withnothing wrong with that, but in my mom'seyes there was My mom aspired Exactly.And you know, she hadn't come fromIreland and worked away at worked herfingers to the bone for me to be workingin a factory.And so we go to the careers officer andhe says, "Oh, you know, what do you wantto do then?" I want to be a manager. Andhe goes, "Okay.What do you want to manage?"I don't know. I don't know, me.>> [laughter]>> Me mom didn't TELL ME THAT.SO,YEAH, SO I LEFT SCHOOL without a cluereally. And um
I knewfrom my my A-level results were notgreat. I mean, I you know, I wasn't astar student by You'll be You'll besurprised to hear, Carl. I mean, Iwasn't a star student at school. I I IgotI got good enough grades in the end. Imean, I Yeah, I just I got good enoughgrades to get into university, but Iwasn't like an A star student oranything like that.Um I wanted to be in a band. That wasreally I was into bands. I was going toa lot of music and I wanted to be in aband and I had a year really of tryingto make it with my band LowdownInternational.Andwe recorded sometracks.There's a an album recently been put outcalled Unseen,which is Birmingham's post-punk bands
'78 to '81. It's on Spotify. LowdownInternational.Batteries not included. And it stillstands up today.>> [laughter]>> And then and you know, I love I loveI used to make music today, very badly,but I you know, I love doing it. And umSo,I had that year to try and make my wayin music. It didn't work and II ended up getting, you know, botheredby me mom to get out of bed in themorning. And soI applied then I didn't have a place atBirmingham University, but I appliedabout 3 days before term started. I gotin and
to study English literature and umSo, I went to uni went to uni inBirmingham and was kind of straddlingthese two worlds really of student life.And me I didn't live at home by then. Iwent to kind of live in flat in the uni,but I was always a bit bit of a homeboyreally. Andbut again, I II had no real idea what I wanted to Ididn't want a proper job. Truthfully, Ididn't. I remember us going to see a guyin the jewelry quarter been sent thereby the job center. And heyou go to work and this this guy justlooked at meand said, "You don't want this job, doyou?">> [laughter]>> I don't know.It was a great bit inTrainspotting where they're all, you
know, the the movie Trainspotting wherethey're sent by thethe employment exchange to go and get aninterview. And one of the guys juststarts swearing and playing up in frontof the And I would never do that. I wasalways too polite, but that's kind ofwhat I felt I didn't want that. ButI you know, it was aFor some reason the you hear stories ofpeople just being allowed to be on thedole for years. Andin my case, they were on my they were onmy case. So I I had to try and get ajob. And um I workedI got a job at the Regional HealthAuthority, West Midlands Regional HealthAuthority, on Hagley Roadwith a some of the most lovely peopleyou could ever hope to meet. In fact,
you know, that was 40-odd years ago. Istill go out regularly, semi-regularly,with half a dozen of those people, whichshows you, you know, how lovely theywere. And it is a great to have thatconnection with those people. But I wasso unsuited to the world of real work.>> [laughter]>> I was It was just not me. I was I was anadministrative officer and umWhen I was there, that's when I startedmy football fanzine. I was I'd writtento loads of newspapersasking, you know, can I get a job? Can Iget a job? It was a tough time for thenewspaper industry in that period in themid-'80s. I know it's tougher now, butit was it was tough then. It was coming
out of that recession in the early '80s.And I just thought, you know what? I'mjust going to do it myself. And therewas enough around football for me towrite about.So that's what I did. And thenhaving got the fanzine up and off theground, then I realized actually it'squite difficult to keep this going.We were very puritan in our ideas.We didn't accept advertising.We insisted the sale price, the coverprice was as low as possible cuz wedidn't want to rip people off.And then, you know, who who loses out inthat scenario? It's us cuz we'reeffectively doing a full-time jobbut earning I mean, literally, I I nevertook a penny from doing the fanzine over
3 years. And then you just thinkthis this doesn't work. It didn't workfrom a financial point of view, but itwas too much work cuz we were doingeverything. We were writing it. We weredesigning it. We weretaking it to the printers. We wereoverseeing the layout. We were thencollecting it in big like big boxes. Imean, we got up to about 8,000 copies.Yeah, driving down to London to take itto Sports Pages, which was a big shop.Somebody would have to go to Sheffieldto take it to a shop in Sheffield.Somebody went to Manchester. So we>> [laughter]>> It was like It was It was It was justthis crazy huge job.
And you know, we all loved doing it andwe all benefited from it, you know, fromdoing this thing. But in the end it I Ifell over. I just got I can't do allthis. AndI think by that stage I'd left the By Bythe end of the fanzine of the late '80s,I'd kind of left the Regional HealthAuthority and at least I'dI kind of could persuade me mom that Iwas doing something worthwhile. And I Ithen just start as as alongside thefanzine I started writing. I did brieflygo to journalism college in Sheffield,but I never finished.Um I sent off on aon spec, not on on a whim, but I sentoff on speca review of the hardcore punk scene inBirmingham,
which was really big. This was a bigpost-punk scene there, Carl. I realizeI'm I'm stretched.>> [laughter]>> But there were bands who were who werevery big and later influential likeNapalm Death. I've heard of them.>> Yeah, Cerebral Fix. And I was a bitolder than most of the bands on thatscene, but I I recognized the scene whenI saw one.And that was massive in Birmingham. So Iwrote to the Observerand said, you know, there's this massivescene in Birmingham. It's hugelyinfluential. It wasn't at that stage,butHi-ho. Anyway, so the Observer thensaid, "Yeah, that's fine. You know, giveme 500 words on it." And I didn't you
know, I had no connections with theObserver. I literally just, you know, Iphoned them up. AndI got in a verbal agreement on thephone. I met my deadline. And then, Imean, this would have been about '89,'90. In the post came a check. This wasfrom Coutts Bank,the Queen's banker,for 100pounds.Blimey. You know, I'd never earnedanything like that from journalism. I'vedone a few little bits and bobs, fewlittle reviews. So then for a maybe ayear or so, I was writing regularly forthe Observer, getting royally paid.Queen's banker is great. And thenbut also then I was I started offering
myself toSounds, the music paper. I became theirman in the Midlands. I was writinglocally for What's On magazine, whichwas edited by Mike Davies, who was areal support of mine. Brilliant man,Mike Davies.And at that stage again,as a freelance you're always juggling.You've always got two or three things onthe go.At that time,incidentally, I should just say, just togo back one step.In the sixth form, I hadworked as a runner at the SundayMercury.So I used to go and watch the Albion.I'd get the 74 or 79 down Soho Road intoBirmingham city center and then workfrom say 6:00 till 11:00
being a copy runner at the SundayMercury, which is the lowest form ofjournalistic life. You're like you'reliterally carrying bits of paper fromone part of the room to another, puttingthem in a basket for the type setters orwhatever. And the journalists who workedthere, and obviously now I look back atit, you know, they were mostly olderblokes,usually in a fug of cigarette smoke,working on a Saturday night. They seemedso miserable.I probably would be too now in theirshoes. But I thought, you know what? Thelast thing I want to be is a journalist.And that's that kind of had put me offit really. So I I kind of denied thistruth to myself that this is really whatI want to do and this is what I'm bornto do. So when I'd started developinginto journalism,
I was I always had this block about theBirmingham Mail. Andat first, you know, I later came towrite for them and was was was But therewas this other thing that people mayremember if they're living in Birminghamcalled the Birmingham Daily News. Andthat felt less kind of stiff, felt lessprim and proper than the BirminghamMail. SoI contacted them. I showed them sentthem a few cuttings.And you know, initially I'll come in fora day, come in for a day.In the end, Birmingham Daily News, thatthey morphed into something called MetroNews, which was a weekly paper.But, I would write I wrote basketballfor them.>> [laughter]>> Thank you to the great Malcolm Boyden
who put me on the basketball beat. But,I did I did basketball and sport forthem. I did arts and entertainment forthem.And I did um news as well. And somewhereit was my you know, I've got still gotcopies at home that I keep where I'dhave my byline on the front page with anews story, in the middle with anentertainment story, and on the backwith a sports story. And that was kindofI felt, yeah, I'm I'm sort of a properjournalist doing doing that. Umwas itCuz I've got a I want to get to the bookin a minute, but was it through thejournalism that you got into radio work?Yes. Yes. So, umI and I was I mean,
you know, you're working your waythrough. I'm probably I was probablylater in my career paththan most people that I was workingwith. I was probably 2 or 3 years olderthan most of the contemporaries on thesame level as me. But, what I had goingfor me was absolutedriven determination, which I'd got frommy mom, I think. And I would It waslike, I'm coming at this late, but Irealized this is what I want to do. Thisis what I was born to do. And because ofmy unfortunate experience with theSunday Mercury, and because nobody hadshown me this path cuz I had no familyconnections or anything, I'd had to findmy way. But, because I'd had to find myway, it was like, right, I'm going to
drive this forward, and I'm not going tostop doing this. I still have thatattitude. Now, nobody's going to push meoff this path. I'm going to do thisthing called journalism. So, thenBirmingham Daily News I'm doing all thiswork for them all all as a freelance.You know, I might go in and get paid aday rates. And I love great peoplethere, by the way. Malcolm Boyden one ofthem, Steve Dyson, who I know you knowwho who former editor of the BirminghamMail who I'm still very good friendswith, Linda Green who went on to becomea a successful novelist. You know,really lovely lovely people. And I justthought, right, this is great. I'mloving this. And I'd got all my otherinterests going, you know, I could stillwrite about music and so on.And then one day,
the you know, the word came down fromthe top, no more freelancers.And all of a sudden, there was no morefreelancers.And I from you know, doing these frontpage, center page art spread, back page,it was like, you've got no income. Thereis nothing there.And the only thing that kept me injournalism at that time, or the onlything that kept me in paid journalism atthat time, was that Malcolm Boyden whowas the sports editorsaid, but I don't know anything aboutbasketball. I can't write a basketballcolumn. And at the time, BirminghamBullets were quite a big basketball bigsport in the city, and in the city, andthey had a home at the National IndoorArena. And they get even if they played
at their smaller venue at Aston VillaLeisure Centre, they'd still get maybe acouple of thousand people there. Youknow, it it was a it was a big sport atthat time. And Boyden said,I don't care. I can't write this. So,there were there were a few weeks whenmy only incomewas £25for writing the basketball column forthe Birmingham Daily News or Metro News.So, thank you to Malcolm Boyden.And at that point, oh my god, what am Igoing to do? And then Boyden was alreadydoing umuh a bit of uh [snorts] footballcommentary for WM. I'd also been becauseof my fanzine work, I'd been a regularguest on WM. They used to get me inloads to cover the gaps. And I thought,
well, I know about football. They don'tmind getting me in.Let me go and blag it. Let me see what Ican do.And I went to see Ian Winter who wasthen the sports editor.And said I'll give me a go.They did give me a go. I was terrible. Ican't tell you how terrible I was atfirst. But,thank you to them, they stuck with me.And I started making my way in radiocovering matches uphill and down dale.And through that you got into a lot moreradio work. We're going to cover that inanother episode.Two big questions I want to get to.>> Yes. Both you and me are very proud ofour strong Birmingham We've faced ourprejudice over accents, haven't we,
Adrian? Yeah. Yeah. And it was reallyweird, wasn't it? You know, you lookback at it at the time, the biggestvoice in West Midlands radio, and Iloved him dearly, and he was a brilliantguy, but was Ed Doolan. He was anAussie. And it like you look at it isn'tit weird that even our local radiostation, the big name the biggest namein local radio, which he was,didn't have a Birmingham accent. It'slike, that's weird.>> got pulled in several times on BBC WMforyour accent's a bit too broad, saidsomebody is.This is local radio.>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You use your dialectwords. Yes. But, what II foundin a way, weirdly, you know, the higherup the BBC you went, the less of aproblem it became. And there would be
people who would say Well, there wouldalways be a patronizing thing about it,though. It was like, oh, you know, yeah,we need we need that kind of accent, youknow. But, I think I caught a caught alucky wave, really. In the the time whenI was starting to break through onradio,uh you had Frank Skinner coming through,Adrian Chiles coming through. And Ithink there was a a brief moment when aWest Midlands accent or a Brummie accentwas seen as the go-to accent, the thingthat they needed. So, I got lucky fromthat point of view. So,in a sense, you can't know the thingsthat you didn't get because of it. Umbut,truthfully, I
I I mean,I I suppose what I would say is that,you know, could I with the knowledgethat I have and the skills that I have,this might sound arrogant, I don't meanit to sound arrogant, could I presentthe Today program on Radio 4? Yeah.Yeah, I could. Would I ever get theopportunity to present the Today programon Radio 4? No. No. And I do thinkaccent and class play into that. Withouta doubt.>> I I have no doubt that and and beinginvolved inthe radio a little bit before you, I andwith having a I think for the first timea really strong Brummie accent on thestation, to think that managers broughtme in to say they'd had complaints aboutmy accent,
is them actually validating accentprejudice. Yeah. But, I I mean, thetruth is, though,that andagain, I'm not speaking on behalf ofRadio WM hereas a you know, there's over the yearswe've had opportunities through andwe've had lots of good people who workedon it. But,the way BBC treats local radio,local radio is governed up there. It'snot governed down here. Local radio isnot run by local people for localpeople. It's run by the BBC with a verycentralized view. In my view, localradio in the West Midlands would soundmassively different to local radio in
Cornwall. And that would sound verydifferent to local radio in Liverpool orGreater Manchester.>> it should if it's local. Exactly. But,you know, the branding across all ofthose radio stations, the jingles,they're all part of a uniform package.And it's a bit Why? Who cares? You know,if if if the jingles in the WestMidlands are different to the jingles inGreater Manchester or the travelnever mind the voices on air and thepresenters, then let's make that. But, Ithink there's been a real centralizingforce in the BBC that has robbed localradio of its local voice. Yeah, of itsidentity. I think you're right on that.Got to make a massive jump now cuz
you've done so much on TV, Radio 4. We Ireally want to talk about it if we cananother time, Adrian, because I've verymuch enjoyed not only listening to you,but learning from you.Talk to me now about your latest bookand why it's so important to you. Yeah.Well, the book is called Where's theMoney Gone? The Battle for the Soul ofEnglish football. And that came to ahead for me when my own club, West Brom,were in real deep financial do-do inlate 2022. Andgroup of supporters called Action forAlbion led by a guy called Ali Jonessaid, look, if we don't stand up as fansand do something, our club is going downthe pan. And not not just having a bad
season, this club will cease to exist.And they organized a very simple protestof shining a light at a particularmoment in the game, and everybody gottheir lights out and shone it inprotest. And then they developed alittle bit of a protest movement afterthat.And having started out as a footballfanzine writer, here I was nearly fourdecades laterfor the first time really in all thattime fearing for the future of myfootball club. And I'd written aboutthese things happening in footballfanzines. Then over the years, I'dbroadcast about it in variousdocumentaries for Radio 4 and 5 Live.Finally, sadly, it was coming home to
roost for me as a fan. This It wasgetting personal now. So, I justthought, right, I've got to tell thisstory both of my journey as a footballwriter and as a fan over these last 40years. But, also, that coincides withthe time in English football whenEnglish football's moved to being run bythe archetypal butcher, baker,candlestick maker. It isn't run by yourlocal businessman anymore. It might berun by an oil state. Your football clubmight be run by a hedge fund based inthe United States. So, I wanted tofollow that path ofhow has that happened to football? Whatforces allowed it to happen?Has that been for good or for ill?Obviously, you know,
drawing from my own personal experienceas a fan, but then building out tosaying, "Okay, this is happening at theAlbion. What's happened to you at Villa?What's happened to people at BirminghamCity? Local clubs, what's happening atWolverhampton Wanderers?" And thenbuilding a bigger picture of Man Cityand Chelsea. And just I didn't want tolecture people. So, the way I did it,and you were kind enough to be a guest,the way I did it was that I gotsupporters' own stories. So, your clubwas threatened with going into oblivion.I mean, it's incredible to think now aswe record this,Villa are third in the Premier League,still with a chance of winning thetitle, but Villa were weeks away from
going bust. And who, you know, peoplekind of think, "Oh, well, somebody wouldhave bought them." Maybe they would,probably they would, possibly theywouldn't. Who, you know, you just don'tknow, and it can, you know, kills a cluband it kills a community if if a Look atSheffield Wednesday now. Exactly. Yeah,you messed up. And um not, you know, notto mention these intangible things,isn't it? But the stress it causes, themental healthconsequences of the, you know,football mean, it maybe footballshouldn't mean as much as it does topeople, but it does. It does. So, wedeal with the world as it is.Um so, I just wanted to tell fans'stories, and then also try andunderstand the bigger story alongsidethat ofhow did these forces come to have power
in what we all think of as fansas our game? Who said that a Russianoligarch could not only take overChelsea, but pump so much money intothem that he utterly distorted thefinancial balance of the game? Who saidan oil state could take over ManchesterCity and get involved in not only thefootball club, but then take overhuge tracts of land in the center ofManchester and embed themselves soclosely in that city that people are nowwary of speaking out about them, whichis an experience I had when I made aradio documentary about them. Same withNewcastle, where people are scared to
speak out about their Saudi owners. So,how did these things come to be, andwhat what direction does it pointfootball in? And is there an alternativeas well?The book is outstanding.>> Thank you.How's it available? Where's itavailable? What etc.>> Yeah, well, if you just put in Where'sthe Money Gone book, or Where's theMoney Gone Byline Books, cuz BylineBooks is thethethe publisher, that you'll get it tothere. Where's the Money Gone BylineBooks, or ask at your local Waterstonesor whatever. And if anybody wants tofind out more about Adrian Goldberg,where do they go? Blimey, everywhere.Uh I'm on Blue Sky Adrian Goldberg. I'mon X. I'm on Facebook. I'm not hard to
get a hold of. I'm really not. Adrian,it's been more than a pleasure, and aprivilege as well. Thanks for joining metoday.>> forward to the next one. Cheers,Cheerio.